Survivors: New Dawn 2 / 2 When First We Practice to Deceive

Home > Episodes > Survivors: New Dawn 2 / 2 When First We Practice to Deceive


Updated: March 01 2022 23:18


Survivors audio dramas from Big Finish

Can Governor Dominic Crayle hide the disturbing secrets of his brutal regime from the unannounced inspection by the government's Law Minister

Survivors - Big Finish - New Dawn 2 - Episode 1 - When First We Practice to Deceive

 

SUMMARY New Dawn 2

WITH THE BACKING of a ranger patrol led by Vanessa Walker, Abby and Jenny arrive in the Yorkshire fiefdom of Dominic Crayle. Returning to the scene of her incarceration and enslavement is distressing for Abby, but she remains determined to expose Crayle's criminality and his wanton abuse of power. It becomes clear that Crayle has gone to great lengths to cover up his crimes. His henchmen have been ordered to hide or destroy evidence, and his subjects have been coached to refute all allegations. As Law Minister Jenny carries out an unannounced inspection of his estate, Crayle remains implacable and unruffled. Confident that no evidence will be uncovered, he remains hospitable and pretends to be nonplussed by the suggestion of wrongdoing. Vanessa and Abby return to the scene of the slave market, but find only burnt ruins and trashed properties. The pair narrowly escape being savaged by vicious dogs primed to attack them. When Jenny is tipped off to look more closely at Crayle's new distillery, she's joined by Vanessa and Abby on a night time raid on the riverside premises. What they discover beneath the floor of the building horrifies all three of them. But Crayle is outraged at their interference in his affairs, and orders his enforcers to ensure that news of their discovery does not reach the wider world. Can Abby, Jenny, Vanessa and the rangers escape from Crayle's clutches, or will they all perish along with the evidence of the Governor's appalling crimes?

COMMENTARY

AFTER FOUR EPISODES in which his crimes and misdemeanours have animated Abby Grant's latest sense of mission, Governor Dominic Crayle is unveiled in his full, appalling form as his affairs are put under scrutiny by Abby and Law Minister Jenny Richards in the explosive events of When First We Practice to Deceive.

Dominic Crayle is a perfect villain for the 'new dawn’' of this new England. Andrew Smith's clever script takes full advantage of just how far the world has moved on from the immediate aftermath years. A combination of entrepreneur, gangster and plantation owner, he's determined to make the very most of the opportunities that the revival of industry, commerce and government afford him for self-aggrandisement.

Crayle is more than a crude thug or enforcer. He’s focused on building up an empire in his enclave, and keeping his affairs free from interference by the central government. If in Bad Blood Emma Maxwell had at least a rudimentary interest in following an independent path that might better suit her neighbours, Crayle’s exclusive motivation is the expansion of his own power and status.

Crayle's exclusive motivation is the expansion of his own power and status

Gareth Armstrong puts in a bravura performance in the role of the duplicitous Governor. His rich vocal tones, together with his natural gravitas, allows Armstrong to switch between the charming and the chilling, depending on the degree of subterfuge Crayle requires. It's a really intelligent approach, equally powerful in moments of restraint and when Crayle unleashes his inner bully.

As the head Ranger Vanessa Walker, Yasmin Mwanza delivers a beautifully judged reading of the role. With a rich emotional range, and able to capture Vanessa’s resolute self-belief, Mwanza brings passion and panache to the part. Her character’s rise to her current position in The Rangers is evidence that, in at least some areas of this new England, aspects of meritocracy and equality have displaced nepotism and prejudice.

There's a degree of tension between Abby and Jenny as their investigation proceeds. Abby is impulsive, impatient and less concerned with the formal process that Law Minister Jenny feels obliged to follow. That's a credible narrative conceit that allows the pair to separate and follow up their enquiries in parallel. But it's also something that adds texture to the dynamic between the two of them that has been evolving since their reunion in Tethered.

As Jenny is accompanied by Crayle on a tour of his sizable walled estate, the sense of tension ratchets up very effectively. Abby and Vanessa in contrast are immediately pitched into a fight for survival as they attempt to locate evidence of Crayle’s slave trade. There are many shocking moments in the story of When First We Practice to Deceive, as the full extent of Crayle's cruelty and barbaric practice is revealed.

Abby is impulsive, impatient and less concerned with the formal process

The episode's final showdown strips away any pretence of Crayle and his enforcers being anything more than murderous thugs. It's a confrontation that has appalling results that put the reunited Jenny and Abby in life-and-death jeopardy once again. Vanessa makes a heroic and selfless sacrifice which enables Abby and Jenny to slip away, even as Crayle and his men are on their heels. Vanessa is such a striking and immediately likeable character that her departure has genuine impact.

Her bravery underpins a thrilling end to proceedings, providing a breathless cliffhanger that sets-up the premise for the concluding episode of the New Dawn series. It's clear that either Crayle or Abby and Jenny are destined to die in the coming confrontation. If the pair of them perish then the truth of Crayle's misrule is likely to be buried with him, leaving the authorities in Cambridge none the wiser.

REVIEW QUOTES

PLAUSIBLE AND CHARMING and with nothing behind his eyes but avarice he's a great villain for the two most hard working altruists in UK post-apocalyptic fiction.
Alasdair Stuart, Sci-Fi Bulletin

DOMINIC CRAYLE IS a terrific creation, brought to life by Gareth Armstrong. His denials are eminently plausible and it’s all too easy to believe them.
Ian McArdell, IndieMacUser

LOOK HARD ENOUGH and you'll always find an ethical dilemma in Andrew Smith's work, and here, it's that question of the burden of truth.
Tony Fyler, Warped Factor


Survivors: Crusade

An original narrated Survivors audiobook, narrated by Carolyn Seymour, is available to buy as a digital download from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - Crusade

"This astute, cautionary tale of the threat that distorted religious certainty can pose to the survivors of The Death is the kind of grown-up and probing storytelling for which the series' setting is so conducive... Seymour's narration is... as perceptive and mellifluous as ever."
Survivors: A World Away

Survivors: New Dawn 2

The second series of this new Survivors audio adventure is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Big Finish - Survivors - New Dawn 2

"The New Dawn series has been a compelling, well-executed foray into a 'future' post-pandemic Britain never before attempted in the Survivors universe. Big Finish regularly jumps around within and beyond the established canon of TV series in its range, and that option would remain open in the world of Survivors. Who knows what will come next? If New Dawn 2 marks the end of Survivors journey on audio, then that will mean that an accomplished, inventive and assured series concludes with a remarkable and satisfying endpoint."
Survivors: A World Away

Survivors: Ghosts and Demons

The original narrated Survivors audiobook, narrated by Carolyn Seymour, is available to buy as a digital download from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - Ghosts and Demons

"Ghosts and Demons is a fantastic addition to the audio literature of Survivors. Author Ethan Milsea uses the cautionary tale of the predatory Tommy as a means to explore the different fears and nightmares that haunt those who have experienced the trauma of The Death and survived. This story, which locks itself in to the first TV series' timeline, delivers admirably on what can often be an elusive ambition: to be both in-keeping with the existing dramatic terrain and to break open new and fertile ground."
Survivors: A World Away

Survivors: New Dawn 1

The first series of this new Survivors audio adventure is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - New Dawn 1

"The first series of New Dawn retains the core sense of jeopardy that made the original post-Death context of Survivors so compelling. Yet it does in a way that is original and genuinely exhilarating. Imagining how the country might have moved on more than two decades after the pandemic provides Survivors with a new 'what if' premise that crackles with potential"
Survivors: A World Away

Survivors: series nine

The ninth series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series nine

"There's still great potential here, as the UK begins to emerge from the dark ages of The Death, for more stories set in this uniquely realised dystopia, should sufficient numbers of those who have yet to purchase copies of this extraordinary audio series belatedly recognise the error of their ways. If that doesn't happen, this will remain a stunning finale for what must be celebrated as a consistently compelling audio drama, 5/5"
Cultbox

Survivors: series eight

The eight series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series eight

"This latest boxset delivers an impressive mix of large scale, high stakes and small scale, intimate stories which set in motion the events which will come to an explosive conclusion in the final set in this current run of post-apocalyptic dramas, 5/5 "
Cultbox

Survivors: series seven

The seventh series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series seven

"At times harrowing, at other moments uplifting, and never anything other than completely riveting listening, this latest series of Survivors audios delivers drama that is simply unmissable. As the series leaves behind the timeline of the TV incarnation of the show, Big Finish's writers, cast and crew are all clearly brimming with fully deserved confidence. The two series of new Survivors audios coming in 2018 could scarcely be a more exciting or (in the best sense of the word) a more unpredictable prospect, 10/10"
Starburst

Survivors: series six

The sixth series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series six

"After five extraordinarily well-received box sets, each of which offered a self-contained and themed collection of four episodes, the sixth series of Survivors audio adventures confidently takes a fresh approach... It's a liberating shift in format and, under the keenly judged direction of Ken Bentley, these scripts make exceptional use of the opportunity to tell diverse, if equally compelling, standalone stories, 10/10"
Starburst

Survivors: series five

The fifth series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to buy (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series five - cover  

"As it explores the highest stakes possible, this develops into the most thrilling and compelling set of stories in Big Finish's Survivors series to date: which, considering the exceptional quality of the drama in the preceding four instalments, is quite some achievement. This is extraordinary, exemplary human drama; by any standard, 10/10"
Starburst

Survivors: series four

The fourth series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to purchase (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series four - cover  

"Intelligent, literate and superbly scripted and performed, this is a post-apocalyptic drama of the highest possible calibre. Determined to avoid the predictable tropes of that genre, it invites its listeners to navigate a moral minefield in a way that few other dramas of this type would attempt. This comes recommended without reservation"
Starburst

Survivors: series three

The third series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to purchase (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series three - cover detail

Survivors: series two

The second series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to purchase (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Survivors - Big Finish - series two - cover detail

Survivors: audio-book

A full-length audiobook of Terry Nation's Survivors novel (in CD and download formats) read by Carolyn Seymour.

Survivors: series one

The first series of new Survivors audio adventures is available to purchase (in CD and download formats) from Big Finish.

Latest updates

 

Review of Crusade audiobook added

Added: 21 June 2022

 

New Dawn 2 reviews added

Added: 02 March 2022

 

New Dawn 1 and Ghosts and Demons reviews added

Added: 03 January 2022

 

Series nine reviews added

Added: 13 July 2019

 

Links

Original TV series (1975-1977)
Survivors remake (2008-2010)